Justice and Mercy – What Does Jack Schaap Deserve?

Jack Schaap, the former pastor of First Baptist Church of Hammond, Indiana, has been arrested and is in jail, at the time of this writing, awaiting sentencing that will occur in January 2013. He has admitted to transporting a 17 year old girl across state lines in order to have sex with her.  The reaction has been loud and angry. Some have said he deserves to “rot in hell.”   There are some who would sentence him to life (he is facing at least 10 years to life).

Update: Schaap was sentenced to 12 years and is now serving his time in a federal prison in Kentucky. His wife moved to a distant state.
Others would sentence him to “time served.” And others (far too many), would simply give him a pass on the basis that “we’re all human,” and attribute his fall to one of the following reasons: (1) he was too stressed; or (2) he had  a lot of pressures at home; or (3) the victim was too blame because she was sexually active and knew what she was doing, and she’s really to blame. I have heard all of those rationales.

What is Justice?

Justice is where penalties are paid. Justice is where punishment is meted out. Justice is where a perpetrator of a crime, or an individual whose actions brought harm to others, is punished. During the trial, the defense attorney is either arguing that his client did not do the crime, and therefore justice would be ill served to convict him, or there were mitigating circumstances which would warrant a jury and judge finding that justice would be better served by finding him not guilty, or guilty of a lesser crime.

Justice is deemed to be sought in a criminal trial by both sides. 

In truth, true justice is seldom sought by either side.
Instead, both sides seek a prescribed justice. The prosecutor seeks a conviction. If a conviction is returned, she will be happy with the fact that justice is served, since justice, to the Prosecutor, is that the defendant has been found guilty. The remainder part of the justice equation for the Prosecutor is the sentencing.

The defense attorney does not argue for justice for his client at the sentencing. Instead, he argues for mercy. He argues for mitigating circumstances or facts which will serve to diminish the punishment. Mercy is very much something that the defendant wishes to have the court display at his trial. The defense attorney sees justice as a variable. So does the Prosecutor. And, so do the Courts. This is because, in a strict sense of the word, it is a variable, if one views justice as being a prescribed application of punishment which is dispensed according to some kind of rule or standard that is set forth in a statute. Thus, for the Prosecutor in a murder trial, justice is a finding of guilty and a subsequent sentencing of the maximum penalty prescribed for the crime.

However, justice is not a variable. Justice is pure. It is immutable as is truth. What is just in one case may not be just in another case. The fact that a jury finds a defendant guilty and the judge sentences him to 10 years does not mean that justice has been done. It merely means that in the eyes of the law, its definition of justice has been served.

In the Jack Schaap case, the Prosecution has its idea of what would be justice in this case. So does the defense. The judge in the case, Rudy Lazano, will be the decider of what is legal justice in Schaap’s case. He elected to deny the Prosecution’s request for 10 years and instead, sentenced Schaap to 12 years. Schaap has filed a notice of appeal.

But, was true justice  done?

Depending on who you ask, justice will not be served at the end of his sentencing, regardless of the outcome.  The 12 years the judge gave was too little for some. For others, it will be perfect and fitting. And, for some (such as Schaap’s family), it will be too much. There will not be a consensus as to whether or not justice has been served.

Jack Schaap entered the court room hoping for mercy, not justice. The family of his victim were hoping for justice. Mercy was not  on their minds. Many church members and Christians around the nation who were “watching” this case were hoping for mercy by the Court. Victims of abuse under the Schaap administration and under his brand of fundamentalism were clearly looking for justice (and perhaps a bit of vengeance, too). They  want a different kind of justice, here. They want vindication. They  want a justice that declares that this man was a fraud, as they’d declared to deaf ears. They  want a justice that is bereft of mercy because they   want an example made of the man who cursed his way to fame, and arrogantly elbowed his way through Fundamentalism, whilst declaring it to be the only legitimate posture of Christianity. 

Some, indeed many of those are still wanting a gaping horde of witnesses in the land of Independent Fundamental Baptists who failed to rebuke and reject Jack Schaap, to recognize the public censure, the disgrace, and the humiliation, yea, all that has befallen this man, as being the justice of God. They want all those who followed Schaap and still follow his idolatrous, man-centric kind of worship, to understand that the punishment that befell and came upon Jack Schaap came not come merely because he had sex with an under-aged teen. They want those witnesses to realize that what has befallen him came because of his arrogant, disgraceful, blasphemous and godless portrayals of Christ and Christianity, and because he felt he could break God’s laws with impunity.  They want all of Fundamentalism to know that although  they would not judge Schaap for his vileness in the pulpit and continued to preach for him and with him in spite of his many aberant doctrinal declarations, God was quite willing to judge him as unfit for the pulpit. 

For them, whatever comes at the hearing is somewhat irrelevant.

For them, they understand that they have been a witness to perfect justice.

And, they will be content that not only has justice been served, but mercy came to Court that day, too.

The End
copyright 2012 Voyle A. Glover

Profaned Pulpit: The Jack Schaap Story (Volume 1)

  • Used Book in Good Condition
A look at the life, ministry and abuses of Jack Schaap, the disgraced pastor of First Baptist Church of Hammond, a Chicago area megachurch, and the influences they had on the Independent Fundamental Baptist Movement.

List Price: $ 13.95 Price: $ 11.29


Leave a Reply